Why expensive cat toys aren’t necessary, according to a cat behaviorist

Cat laying on its back playing with a wand toy
(Image credit: Getty Images)

When you’re a cat parent, it can be tempting to want to spend money on your cat. Of course, having pets does cost money, and you’ll need to buy things like food, toys, and treats fairly regularly.

However, while it’s a great idea to buy some of the best cat toys or best cat treats now and again, it’s not always the best idea to buy the most expensive interactive toys, gadgets, and pieces of furniture. They won’t always work the way we think they will, and we’ve all seen cats ignore fancy new toys in favor of the cardboard boxes they arrived in!

Certified cat behaviorist Saba Sayyed, known as A Cat Behaviorist, has explained why the most glitzy and expensive products aren’t always the best – to help us save money and keep our cats happy and healthy at the same time!

1. Diffusers and calming sprays aren’t magic: “They can help for a short time, but they don’t address why your cat is stressed,” explains Sayyed.

If we really want to help our cats, it’s best that we get to the root cause of their anxiety or frustration. Otherwise, we’re just papering over the issue.

2. Cats aren’t bothered about price tags: As Sayyed puts it, and as many of us cat parents know, “Your cat isn’t impressed by expensive toys – they’re happy with a crumpled paper ball or a simple wand toy. What they really need is ways to exhaust their physical and mental energy without causing chaos in your home.”

3. It’s better to understand than guess: The more you understand your cat’s behavior, the less you need to guess what the issue is.

“This means fewer unnecessary vet visits and fewer products gathering dust in your home. You will know what works and what does not work for you once you decode their personality,” Sayyed explains.

4. Marketing gimmicks fool us: “Food labels, litter claims, and gadgets all sound promising,” she continues, “But what your cat truly needs is often simpler and far less expensive – quality food, a stress-free environment, and the behavior training from you!”

We always bear this in mind when writing our buying guides to the best products – we try to test as much as we can ourselves, so that we can really give you the best recommendations.

5. Prevention will save you money: When it comes to issues like anxiety, aggression, and problems using the litter box (such as your cat peeing outside the litter box), it’s better to prevent it in the first place. The more clued up you are on cat behavior, the more you’re likely to save on vet bills and expensive fixes.

6. Invest in knowledge: “Cat behavior training equips you to truly understand your cat,” says Sayyed. “When you know what they need, you’ll stop buying unnecessary products and focus on what actually works.”

If you’d like more advice for your feline friend, here are some common cat behavior problems solved and tips for training a cat. We also have rounded up some weird cat behaviors that you might be worried about.

Adam England
Freelance Writer

Adam is a freelance journalist specialising in pets, music and culture, and mental health and wellbeing. He investigates and writes the large majority of news on PetsRadar, and collaborates with veterinary experts to produce informative pet care content.

Adam has a journalism degree from Southampton Solent University and a masters degree in Magazine Journalism from Cardiff University. He was previously senior editor at dog advice website DogTime.com, and has also written for The Independent, GoodToKnow and Healthline.

He owns two rescue cats, Bunny and Dougie, and has also previously had a rabbit, fish and Roborovski dwarf hamsters.

Read more
Close up of grey cat looking angry
Trying to address your cat’s behavior but nothing’s working? This feline behaviourist explains why
Megan's cat Chilli sniffing the Catit Groovy Fish, one of the best cat toys
The 6 best cat toys, tried and tested by our feline friends
Cat lying on a bed looking slumped over and bored
Is your cat bored? Watch out for these 9 tell-tale signs, according to a vet
White cat standing on hind legs playing with a ball on a wire stick in the air
8 fun games to play with cats (affordable and easy)
Ginger kitten lying on a bed with its claws on a blue fish teaser toy on a yellow string
How to play with a cat the right way
Cat playing with teaser wand
Best interactive cat toys: 6 toys tested and approved by real cats and their owners
Latest in Cats
Megan's nonna's cat lying down next to the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit
I test pet products for a living, and this discount on the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit is not to be missed
Yaheetech Large Cat Tower with PetsRadar deals graphic
Hurry! Our top-rated cat tower is 40% off right now in the Amazon Big Spring Sale
Shark Air Purifier in a room with a man, dog, a child playing, with a petsradar deals overlay to the right hand side
Not a drill! Shark’s Air Purifier is $130 off in the Amazon Big Spring Sale – and it’s going straight in my basket
Megan's PetPivot Autoscooper 11 with a Petsradar deals overlay to the right hand side
This automatic cat litter box changed my life! And it’s now under $200 (not a typo!) in the Amazon Big Spring Sale
Cat looking at vacuum cleaner with suspicion
How to spring clean without causing your cat anxiety, according to an expert
Katherine Kiefer holds Aggie in her arms after being reunited
​​Reunion between 82-year-old and her cat after Palisades fires goes viral and raises over $35,000
Latest in News
Megan's nonna's cat lying down next to the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit
I test pet products for a living, and this discount on the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit is not to be missed
Yaheetech Large Cat Tower with PetsRadar deals graphic
Hurry! Our top-rated cat tower is 40% off right now in the Amazon Big Spring Sale
Shark Air Purifier in a room with a man, dog, a child playing, with a petsradar deals overlay to the right hand side
Not a drill! Shark’s Air Purifier is $130 off in the Amazon Big Spring Sale – and it’s going straight in my basket
Megan's PetPivot Autoscooper 11 with a Petsradar deals overlay to the right hand side
This automatic cat litter box changed my life! And it’s now under $200 (not a typo!) in the Amazon Big Spring Sale
Cat looking at vacuum cleaner with suspicion
How to spring clean without causing your cat anxiety, according to an expert
Dog looking over the back seat of a car
‘Some dogs are very clear when they’re unhappy in the car – but others are more passive’: Behaviorist warns that signs of distress are easily missed