Transition your dog from crate to free roaming with this simple advice from an expert trainer

Australian Shepherd puppy lying in his crate
(Image credit: Getty Images)

Disclaimer: Unless specifically stated, any expert comments quoted in this news piece have been taken directly from the Instagram post cited below.

When you first brought your new bundle of fluff home, it's likely that figuring out how to crate train a dog was high on your priority list.

But now that your little one has grown into a fully-fledged adolescent or adult, you may be wondering if it's okay to start transitioning them out of their crate and letting them free roam around the house.

Well, according to expert trainer Carolyn, founder of Good Dog Training, free roaming is ideal for dogs that don't do well in confinement and for calmer pups who have been taught how to handle freedom.

If you're thinking of weaning your dog off their crate, here's a few thoughts from Carolyn that you'll want to consider...

1. How destructive are they? "If you're meeting your dog's needs, leaving them with a few tasty chews, and setting them up for success, will they be destructive?," asks Carolyn.

"If you put the garbage can away, pick up shoes, close bedroom doors, will your dog be okay with a bone or tendon to chew on? 

"If your dog is relatively destruction-free, try not crating them the next time you leave."

2. Is your dog house trained? "If your dog is house trained or you have a dog door, then it may be time to start weaning off the crate," Carolyn advises.

"If your dog is still pottying inside or marking on things when you're no watching, crating may be best for a bit."

When it comes to phasing out the crate, Carolyn says it's important to start slowly.

"Start by leaving your dog loose while you go pick up groceries. Did they do okay? Great! Try a bit longer next time. 

"Did they struggle? Chew up the couch or pee on the floor? Let's try to set them up for success next time and reevaluate."

Carolyn adds that starting at night tends to be easier than starting during the day — and there's a good reason for that.

"When the house is dark and everyone is asleep, the dogs tend to chill out and sleep too," she explains. "You're also home to hear any 'I need to potty' cries or sounds of mass destruction."

When working to transition your dog from their crate to free roaming, try not to take an all or nothing approach as these things take time. 

"You don't have to go from always crating to leaving your dog completely loose in the house all the time. You can try using baby gates to confine your dog to a larger area and see how they do," suggests Carolyn. 

The only way you'll know how your dog will do out of their crate is to try it and see. Carolyn says that if you find they're struggling, that's a signal they're not ready yet and that's okay!

"Every dog is a bit different in how quickly they're able to progress to being loose in the house. But if you’re thinking about it, it may be worth just trying it. You might be surprised."

Kathryn Williams
Freelance writer

Kathryn is a freelance writer who has been a member of the PetsRadar family since it launched in 2020. Highly experienced in her field, she's driven by a desire to provide pet parents with accurate, timely, and informative content that enables them to provide their fur friends with everything they need to thrive. Kathryn works closely with vets and trainers to ensure all articles offer the most up-to-date information across a range of pet-related fields, from insights into health and behavior issues to tips on products and training. When she’s not busy crafting the perfect sentence for her features, buying guides and news pieces, she can be found hanging out with her family (which includes one super sassy cat), drinking copious amounts of Jasmine tea and reading all the books.

Read more
Close up of pug puppy looking sad
Expert trainer shares her thoughts on the puppy blues
White dog pulling on leash
Here’s how to stop your dog from running out of the front door, according to an expert
Puppy on leash with owner in background
‘It takes two to pull, and once you develop this habit, it can be hard to break’: Vet shares tips for leashing training a puppy
Dog laying on the couch looking bored
Are you always entertaining your dog? One trainer explains why it’s fine to let your dog be bored
Dog walking towards camera carrying leash in his mouth
Trainer shares six simple skills you can put into action to give your dog confidence and freedom out walking
Man waving to woman walking dog in public park
Here’s how to manage your dog around other dogs and people in public
Latest in Dogs
Megan's nonna's cat lying down next to the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit
I test pet products for a living, and this discount on the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit is not to be missed
Jan, a dog behaviorist, playing with her dog Cassie
I’m a dog behaviorist and these are my top tips for ‘bulletproof’ reliable recall
Dog looking over the back seat of a car
‘Some dogs are very clear when they’re unhappy in the car – but others are more passive’: Behaviorist warns that signs of distress are easily missed
Bull Terrier laying on grass with tongue out
Bull Terriers have a unique ‘Marmite’ look but they can be energetic, playful pets
Cute Labrador puppy on sofa
A pet’s ‘cuteness’ can influence intentions to book Airbnbs and rental stays, suggests new study
King Charles in front of a union jack flag
King Charles brings home his first puppy in over three decades – here’s what we know so far
Latest in News
Megan's nonna's cat lying down next to the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit
I test pet products for a living, and this discount on the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit is not to be missed
Yaheetech Large Cat Tower with PetsRadar deals graphic
Hurry! Our top-rated cat tower is 40% off right now in the Amazon Big Spring Sale
Shark Air Purifier in a room with a man, dog, a child playing, with a petsradar deals overlay to the right hand side
Not a drill! Shark’s Air Purifier is $130 off in the Amazon Big Spring Sale – and it’s going straight in my basket
Megan's PetPivot Autoscooper 11 with a Petsradar deals overlay to the right hand side
This automatic cat litter box changed my life! And it’s now under $200 (not a typo!) in the Amazon Big Spring Sale
Cat looking at vacuum cleaner with suspicion
How to spring clean without causing your cat anxiety, according to an expert
Dog looking over the back seat of a car
‘Some dogs are very clear when they’re unhappy in the car – but others are more passive’: Behaviorist warns that signs of distress are easily missed