If a dog smells you, be sure not to make this common mistake

Dog sniffing woman’s hand
(Image credit: Getty Images)

If a dog comes up to you, your first instinct might be to pet them. Of course, it’s good advice generally not to pet dogs you don’t know, but it can be tempting to reach out if they’re the ones approaching us to smell us first.

However, a dog coming up and smelling you is not necessarily an invitation for you to touch them – and not all dogs are comfortable with us doing so. Rather, it’s best to have some of the best dog treats on hand to make the dog feel more at ease.

Certified dog trainer Melissa Goodman of Mission Pawsitive has explained everything we need to know in a recent Instagram post, and it’s given us plenty of food for thought – and it’ll help us ensure we keep the dogs around us as comfortable as possible, too!

In Goodman’s video, she’s being approached by a dog, Hazel. “Have you made this assumption before?” Goodman asks, “See how she’s extending her back legs as far as she can? She’s not asking me to pet her right now.”

She says ‘good girl’ and throws treats for Hazel, who appears to simply be checking her out and gathering information by scent, rather than wanting to be touched.

“She kind of goes, ‘Oh wait, I think I pushed myself too far. Uh oh, now what do I do,” says Goodman about Hazel, explaining that dogs in this situation can have their fight or flight instincts kick in.

She adds in the caption, “If I reached out to pet her, she would have jumped back because she definitely had no interest in interacting with me. If you do it to the wrong dog, that’s how you get bitten.”

Where Hazel is leaning forward and shifting her weight, it’s so she can move away quickly if she needs to – knowing how to read dog body language can be so important! This is why Goodman gives her a treat – it prevents her from feeling stuck in the situation, but also rewards her for being brave. And, as she summarizes, “Unless a dog makes it very obvious they want physical affection from me, I don’t pet them.”

While it’s totally fine for dogs not to want to be touched all the time, it’s a good idea to keep an eye on your own pup to see if they exhibit anxious behavior on a regular basis. These eight reasons why your dog is anxious (and how to help them) could be eye-opening.

Adam England
Freelance Writer

Adam is a freelance journalist specialising in pets, music and culture, and mental health and wellbeing. He investigates and writes the large majority of news on PetsRadar, and collaborates with veterinary experts to produce informative pet care content.

Adam has a journalism degree from Southampton Solent University and a masters degree in Magazine Journalism from Cardiff University. He was previously senior editor at dog advice website DogTime.com, and has also written for The Independent, GoodToKnow and Healthline.

He owns two rescue cats, Bunny and Dougie, and has also previously had a rabbit, fish and Roborovski dwarf hamsters.

Read more
Dog laying on back in field
Trainer warns dog owners that dog body language is often misinterpreted – here’s what to watch out for
Bulldog with toilet roll in his mouth
If your dog does something you don’t like, try this expert-approved response to help you adjust your mindset
Owner comforting a scared dog
It’s fine to pet your dog when they’re scared, despite the outdated advice you might have heard
Dog jumping up at child
Try these expert-approved effective tips if your dog jumps up to greet people
Woman stopped with dog who she has been walking on a leash in a park
Trainer shares simple steps to take if your dog’s finding things difficult when you’re out walking
Man waving to woman walking dog in public park
Here’s how to manage your dog around other dogs and people in public
Latest in Dogs
Megan's nonna's cat lying down next to the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit
I test pet products for a living, and this discount on the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit is not to be missed
Jan, a dog behaviorist, playing with her dog Cassie
I’m a dog behaviorist and these are my top tips for ‘bulletproof’ reliable recall
Dog looking over the back seat of a car
‘Some dogs are very clear when they’re unhappy in the car – but others are more passive’: Behaviorist warns that signs of distress are easily missed
Bull Terrier laying on grass with tongue out
Bull Terriers have a unique ‘Marmite’ look but they can be energetic, playful pets
Cute Labrador puppy on sofa
A pet’s ‘cuteness’ can influence intentions to book Airbnbs and rental stays, suggests new study
King Charles in front of a union jack flag
King Charles brings home his first puppy in over three decades – here’s what we know so far
Latest in News
Megan's nonna's cat lying down next to the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit
I test pet products for a living, and this discount on the Neakasa P2 Pro Grooming Kit is not to be missed
Yaheetech Large Cat Tower with PetsRadar deals graphic
Hurry! Our top-rated cat tower is 40% off right now in the Amazon Big Spring Sale
Shark Air Purifier in a room with a man, dog, a child playing, with a petsradar deals overlay to the right hand side
Not a drill! Shark’s Air Purifier is $130 off in the Amazon Big Spring Sale – and it’s going straight in my basket
Megan's PetPivot Autoscooper 11 with a Petsradar deals overlay to the right hand side
This automatic cat litter box changed my life! And it’s now under $200 (not a typo!) in the Amazon Big Spring Sale
Cat looking at vacuum cleaner with suspicion
How to spring clean without causing your cat anxiety, according to an expert
Dog looking over the back seat of a car
‘Some dogs are very clear when they’re unhappy in the car – but others are more passive’: Behaviorist warns that signs of distress are easily missed