How we test, review and rate products on PetsRadar

Woman sitting down in a field at sunset, holding a ball in her hand which her dog is jumping up at
(Image credit: Getty Images/StefaNikolic)

On PetsRadar, we're dedicated to providing independent advice you can trust. Our team consists of experienced writers who all share two things in common: a passion for pets and a commitment to giving readers the best advice possible. We work alongside qualified vets and accredited trainers to produce accurate, useful, and up-to-date content to help you take care of your pets.

When it comes to our buying guides and reviews, we test the products we recommend whenever possible – and as pet parents ourselves, we know what to look for. We put products through rigorous testing, following standardized criteria that consider factors like quality, value for money, safety, and, most importantly, whether they're approved by our pets.

To learn more about how we test at PetsRadar, what our star ratings mean, and a little bit about our testers, you can find more information below:

How PetsRadar tests products

Here's our step-by-step process for testing products:

Step 1: Expert research
If we're reviewing health-related products or food, we consult our in-house vet team about the best ingredients to look out for (and the ones to avoid). We also ask the experts your frequently asked questions, like how to choose the right product and the best way to use it. This information gives us a better understanding before we start our next stage of research...

Step 2: Product research
Once we know what we're looking for, we browse the top pet retailers and hand-select the products that meet our criteria. Using our expertise, we check the ingredients and materials to ensure they're safe for your pet to use. For things like puzzle feeders and bowls, we'll keep an eye out for labels like 'BPA-free' and make a note of this in the guide. We try to include a variety of products that suit every budget, style, age, and breed.

Step 3: Online review check
Before we go ahead with testing, we check the online reviews to see what people are saying.

Cat sitting in front of a food bowl while a person opens a can of food above him

(Image credit: Getty Images/CasarsaGuru)
Our promise to you

1. Our reviews are independent and brands won't sway our opinions.

2. When we say we've tested a product, this has been done by real pet parents, just like you.

3. We consult qualified vets before recommending health products.

Step 4: Product testing
Once we're confident in our selection, we find out what our pets think about the products. Our writers, including Georgia Guerin, Megan Milstead, Alexis de Leaver, and Kathryn Williams, will either give them to their own pets, or to one of our trusted testers within Future Plc. To ensure each product is tested fairly and to the same criteria, they'll answer the same set of questions.

Step 5: Reviewing
When the results are in, our writers compile them into a buying guide where you can compare all your options. We usually round up our top six picks, and if a product doesn't make the cut, we’ll include it in our 'other products to consider' section. Where possible, we include images of our pets trying the product to give you a better sense of how it looks and the overall user experience.

Who tests products for PetsRadar?

Our testing team is made up of PetsRadar's writers and pet parents who work at Future Plc. Here's a bit about them:

What our star ratings mean

Swipe to scroll horizontally
5 starsAn exceptional product without any significant faults. Highly recommended - do not hesitate to purchase.
4.5 starsAn excellent product with minor weaknesses that are subjective.
4 starsA great product that has a few areas for improvement.
3.5 starsA good product, but it didn't perform as well as its competitors.

You can also learn about content funding on PetsRadar and more about us.

Megan Milstead
Staff Writer

Megan is a Staff Writer on PetsRader, covering news, features and buying guides. She has a wealth of experience looking after animals, having grown up with dogs, cats and horses all of her life. She’s particularly interested in pet happiness and behavior, which she loves to research in her spare time. You’ll often find her watching webinars on reactivity in dogs or researching cat body language. She loves going the extra mile for her cats Chilli and Nala (who also help out with testing the best products for our buying guides).

Megan studied BA Journalism at the University of Westminster, where she specialized in lifestyle journalism and was editor of Smoke Radio’s online magazine. She also graduated from West Herts College with a Level 3 Extended Diploma in Journalism. Before joining the PetsRadar family last year, she worked on the editorial team at Harrods and has spent most of her career writing for specialized titles, like RunningShoesGuru, Licklist and Mr. After Party.

Megan works alongside qualified vets and accredited trainers to ensure you get the best advice possible. She is passionate about finding accurate and helpful answers to your pet-related questions.